The Truth Always Comes Out And It Almost Never Works Out Well

Robin Judson |

It was such a disappointment!  We sent the resume of this great analyst, call him Joe Smith, to one of our clients, ABC Hedge Fund.  Joe completed a two year analyst program, top of his class, at a well-regarded investment bank.  He then spent two years at a private equity fund where he worked on three closed investments.

There was a love fest going on.  They all thought about investing the same way.  My client saw Joe as a great cultural fit too.  Junior staff really liked him.  Joe nailed the personality test and the case study.  They knew a lot of the same people and not only did the formal references check out well, the backdoor references were even stronger.  Joe signed the consent form for the background check and waited for the approval to submit his resignation.

About ten days later, we received a call from our client.  There was a problem with the background check.  Joe’s resume showed that his undergraduate GPA was 3.62; his SATs were 1510.  The background check showed a GPA of 3.41 and SATs of 1330.  Our client was not concerned with the actual numbers.  He was upset that Joe falsified information on his resume.  It was a small lie but how could they trust him?  We called Joe to tell him.

Joe admitted that he purposely boosted his scores because he was afraid that his real scores were not strong enough to land interviews with the funds we represent.  He may have been correct but we thought he was terrific and we would have pushed hard to win him an interview.  Instead, he lost out on a role that would have been a great fit, we could not work with him again and our client and the staff there viewed him as less than honest.

There was an even worse story many years ago.  We placed a San Francisco- based candidate named Alan in a bank job in New York.  He had a new baby at home and his wife stayed behind to pack and oversee the sale of their house.  Alan quit his old job and started the new job before the background check came through at the client’s insistence.  At that time, the internet could not be relied on for personal information and the background checks took weeks to complete.

Six weeks later, we received a call from HR that a one year period of unemployment a few years earlier had actually been two years and Alan had altered his start and end dates for the adjacent jobs.  HR and the hiring managers at the bank were so happy with Alan and his work that if he would account for that year, he could remain in his new job anyway.  He refused to explain the gap and the bank fired him.  He ended up unemployed and had to return to San Francisco.  Fortunately he had not yet sold his house.  I never found out what that gap was but the whole thing broke my heart.  I was sick over it but it was his fault.

It is shocking how often we find that resumes include purposely-inaccurate information.  Sometimes, it’s the completion of a degree or obtaining a professional license.  We have even seen candidates who worked at the original Chase Manhattan Bank (prior to the acquisition of JP Morgan) claim that they worked at JP Morgan.

I choose to believe that at least some of these “errors” are due to naiveté and not character flaws.  At some point, the truth comes out and it almost never works out well.

If you found this article helpful you might also want to check out, “How Traders in Investment Banking Are Escaping Trading

Private Equity Career News

David Toll | Toll Publications

... Read Article


The #METOO Era: Thoughts For The Investment Community

Robin Judson |

The recent Bloomberg article by Gillian Tan and Katia Porzecanski called Wall Street Rule for the #Me Too Era: Avoid Women at All Cost focused on the worries of men on Wall Street who work with young women.  The article highlights the Pence Effect, in which men avoid solo contact with younger (read more junior) women.  This phenomenon conflicts directly with

... Read Article


Why Mentoring Matters, and How to Get Started

Lizz Schumer | New York Times

My first desk had an inert hand grenade in one corner and a notebook in another. As a public relations assistant to Kathy Hochul, the Erie County clerk at the time, my job was to make the office (and by extension, Ms. Hochul) look good. The grenade reminded me that it took decisive confidence to

... Read Article


At Hedge Funds, Where Are the Women?

Rob Copeland | Wall Street Journal

At hedge funds, women do just about any job—but rarely run the money. Of the largest 50 U.S. hedge funds by assets under management, only two have women as their top investment executive, according to a Wall Street Journal analysis of data from researcher Absolute Return. In that same group of 50 hedge funds, half

... Read Article


How To Get Wall Street Recruiters To Respond To You

Dan Butcher | eFinancial Careers

Sometimes you hit send on an email or leave a voicemail and it’s as if your message entered a black hole, especially when dealing with Wall Street recruiters. They tend to be busy, and they are often only searching for a few specific skills sets or types of experience at any given time based on

... Read Article


Robin Judson Partners Brings Home Two Awards

Robin Judson |

We are proud to be the recipients of two ACQ5 Awards for 2017: US-HR/Recruitment Firm of the Year (Hedge Funds) and US – Gamechanger of the Year, Robin Judson, Robin Judson Partners!  

... Read Article


7 Ways to Nail a Telephone Interview

Robin Judson |

We see more and more of our clients conducting introductory interviews by phone instead of in person.  We also use telephone interviews to screen potential candidates.  The telephone interview differs in numerous ways from the in-person interview.  What is the best way to nail the interview and make it to the next round? As an

... Read Article


The Art of Resigning

Robin Judson |

Congratulations, you have landed the job of your dreams or maybe just a better role than what you have.  You cannot wait to resign but hold on.  It’s important to think through the process. What do you need to do to get ready to join the new employer?  Are references all done?  Did you have

... Read Article