Finding The Right Financial Recruiter


Finding the right professional staff can be challenging for a financial firm.

As financial recruiters, we understand the consequences of making even a single bad hire. Our years of experience in financial recruitment have provided a key takeaway — asking the right questions is only part of finding and successfully placing a long-term hire.

We Know What Can Go Wrong. 

Over the years, we have seen it all: Not asking the right interview questions, not having enough time to interview all the candidates thoroughly enough to compare them, frustration over sifting through candidates from recruiters who are new in their roles or don’t understand the role or fit. So often, we see firms focus on the big picture and leave the details unexplored.  

Initial interviews need to involve questions that will ignite more insightful views of the candidate, the role and how they truly fit into your company’s culture and long – term goals. 

The interview process takes time. The most efficient option is to hire a professional recruiting firm. Candidates for roles in private equity, hedge funds, and investment banks need to be carefully vetted. Only a recruiter can provide that dedicated time and efficient process.

Delegate The Daily Management of The Hiring Process. 

If you need to free yourself up to manage your own business, while maintaining your own hiring momentum, partner with a recruiting firm. 

Not all recruiters are the same. Anyone can flog resumes around in the hope that one is the right fit. Our recruiters take great care to ensure that all stakeholders work toward the same goal and that everyone’s interests are aligned. We believe a good hire starts with the screening process. 

We pride ourselves on the three simple reasons our screening process is so successful: 

1. We are scrupulously honest. 

We are honest, sometimes to our own detriment, but it’s been our experience over the years that being candid works for our process. We don’t stretch the truth. We work very hard to give you the straight story.

We are direct with candidates and clients alike. Because we strive to be authentic, candidates and clients know that we’re always representing them accurately. We never misrepresent a job to a candidate and likewise, we never misrepresent a candidate to a Client.

2.We work diligently to make the right fit. 

Our job is to find the right candidate for your role. We know that it is expensive to recruit. That’s why our firm’s partners conduct our searches for private equity and hedge fund investment professionals and investment bankers, not inexperienced associates looking for a set of key words on a resume.

We also take into consideration what our candidates’ long term career goals are and what a client’s firm can offer them. If they take the role, we want to make sure it’s with a place they will want to stay for the long term. If goals don’t align, we know that is unlikely to be a strong match. 

For us, it’s important that we take the time to get to know our clients and their culture. Not all environments are identical, so it’s critical that we consider all the factors that make up a firm’s culture. 

What are the values, behaviors and experiences of the organization?

Does the client describe the actual culture or the aspirational culture? 

What kind of personality does a candidate need in order to fit there?

By making sure that we understand our client’s culture, our recruiters can better assess which candidate will best fit as a new member of that organization. 

The reason we have a track record of long-term tenure for our placements is that we do take the time to get to know all parties involved. 

3.We evolve with the Industry. 

Our process has worked for us for many years, but our process evolves with the market. We stay on top of industry trends, but we find it invaluable to learn from every candidate and every client. 

It’s important not to get stuck in one way of doing things. Taking a dynamic approach that entails some adaptation of the new, while we remain true to core values, has brought us success throughout the years. 

Don’t Waste Time on Another Hire You’re Unsure About. 

Download our recruitment readiness audit to uncover how your organization can make the most of your next recruiting partnership.

Not ready for a recruiter just yet? Here are some creative interview options to keep in mind. 

Interview Over Lunch

Going out for a meal can reveal a lot about someone. 

Is the candidate considerate of others? 

Do they display good manners?

Do they get irritated or flustered over the service? 

These behaviors may indicate how the candidate might treat other staff or how they’ll respond in a stressful project situation.

Alternatively, send the candidate out with the team and leave the hiring manager behind. They will see if the candidate will mesh with the rest of the team. What are their initial impressions or takeaways?

Take a Tour 

Stay in the building and show candidates around your company. If confidentiality is not an issue, introduce them to some colleagues. Are they genuinely interested in how the company is set up, how people work together and the true culture of the office?  It will also provide the candidate with a sense of the firm’s day to day environment.

Ask Insightful Questions 

Astute candidates will be prepared for all the canned interview questions,and will try to find clever ways to turn any negatives into positives. 

To get beyond rehearsed answers, ask questions that help assess the candidate’s personality. Behavioral questions or brain teasers help to see how creatively a candidate thinks on his feet and if they can handle the unique challenges of the position. 

Try to go deeper with your interview questions, for example: 

Tell me about the worst mistake you made in your current role. How did you handle it and what did you learn?  

What do you do when you have a fundamental disagreement with your boss? 

How do you stay motivated when work becomes discouraging and markets turn against you?

How would your co-workers, friends and family describe you?  

If you found this article interesting, you might also like our post, “7 Ways to Nail a Telephone Interview” 

A Simple Approach to Successful Interviewing

Robin Judson |

Those of you who have worked with us know that we always emphasize one key approach to interviews. We always say, be yourself.  Be your best self but be yourself. Don’t try to be what you think the interviewer wants.  You don’t really know what they want.  You could lose the opportunity because they perceive

... Read Article

How to Make Remote Hires Feel Like a Part of the Team

Julie Bawden-Davis, Writer/Author/Publisher/Speaker, Garden Guides Press | Garden Guides Press

Onboarding work from home (WFH) employees can be challenging. Virtually replacing the face-to-face interactions that offer ample opportunities to make new employees feel at home takes creative planning and flexibility. According to the 2020 State of Remote Work Report: Unlocking Opportunity conducted by Hired, a marketplace that matches tech talent with companies, “97 percent of respondents said they are either

... Read Article

Finding The Right Financial Recruiter


Finding the right professional staff can be challenging for a financial firm. As financial recruiters, we understand the consequences of making even a single bad hire. Our years of experience in financial recruitment have provided a key takeaway — asking the right questions is only part of finding and successfully placing a long-term hire. We

... Read Article

Pandemic Crisis Sends Another 6.6 Million Americans Into Unemployment

Contributed by Scott A. Scanlon, Editor-in-Chief; Dale M. Zupsansky, Managing Editor; and Stephen Sawicki, Managing Editor | Hunt Scanlon Media

Over 17 million Americans have now filed for unemployment benefits over just the last three weeks. The speed and scale of the job losses are historic and unprecedented. April 9, 2020 – Americans displaced by the coronavirus crisis again filed unemployment claims in historic numbers with the last seven days, with the Labor Department reporting

... Read Article

The #METOO Era: Thoughts For The Investment Community

Robin Judson |

The recent Bloomberg article by Gillian Tan and Katia Porzecanski called Wall Street Rule for the #Me Too Era: Avoid Women at All Cost focused on the worries of men on Wall Street who work with young women.  The article highlights the Pence Effect, in which men avoid solo contact with younger (read more junior) women.  This phenomenon conflicts directly with

... Read Article

Why Mentoring Matters, and How to Get Started

Lizz Schumer | New York Times

My first desk had an inert hand grenade in one corner and a notebook in another. As a public relations assistant to Kathy Hochul, the Erie County clerk at the time, my job was to make the office (and by extension, Ms. Hochul) look good. The grenade reminded me that it took decisive confidence to

... Read Article

At Hedge Funds, Where Are the Women?

Rob Copeland | Wall Street Journal

At hedge funds, women do just about any job—but rarely run the money. Of the largest 50 U.S. hedge funds by assets under management, only two have women as their top investment executive, according to a Wall Street Journal analysis of data from researcher Absolute Return. In that same group of 50 hedge funds, half

... Read Article

How To Get Wall Street Recruiters To Respond To You

Dan Butcher | eFinancial Careers

Sometimes you hit send on an email or leave a voicemail and it’s as if your message entered a black hole, especially when dealing with Wall Street recruiters. They tend to be busy, and they are often only searching for a few specific skills sets or types of experience at any given time based on

... Read Article